Halloween Party Flipped Chat Profile

They had you randomly pick one and they wrote a one on it. Then had you pick another one and wrote a two on it. Then had you pick one more and wrote a three on it and a four on the other one the envelopes weren't going to be start opening until the last four hours. Then the time came to open the first envelopes. You pulled out the one with the number one on it. And handed it to Alice to open and read.